Agent Copilot AI
← Blog

guide

How to Find Real Estate Comps in My Area: A Checklist

By Christiano Sampaio Β· October 20, 2026

How to Find Real Estate Comps in My Area: A Checklist

You can find real estate comps in my area using free public sources like county assessor records and Zillow's sold listings, plus your MLS if you have access. The hard part is knowing which comps to trust. This guide gives you specific discard thresholds: half-mile radius, 90-day recency, and rules for tossing foreclosures and family transfers.

Key takeaways

  • Pull raw sold data from free county assessor sites or Zillow, but rely on MLS sold data for the most reliable condition notes and concessions.
  • Filter comps by a half-mile to one-mile radius and 90-day recency, discarding anything across natural boundaries or older than six months.
  • Throw out non-arm's-length sales like family transfers, foreclosures, and flips because their prices do not reflect the open market.
  • Adjust comp prices using the paired-sales method, and discard any comp if total adjustments exceed 15% of its original sale price.
  • Build trust with sellers by showing them the discarded comps alongside the three to six solid ones used to determine their home value.

What exactly counts as a real estate comp?

A comp is a recently sold home similar to your subject property in location, size, age, and condition, used to estimate what a buyer would actually pay. A nearby listing that never sold is not a comp. Neither is a sale where the seller was a bank, a relative, or a distressed owner, because those prices don't reflect the open market.

Arm's-length sales only

An arm's-length sale means a willing seller and willing buyer, no family relationship, no foreclosure, no shared ownership, and typical market exposure. Fannie Mae's appraisal standards require appraisers to use arm's-length comparables for exactly this reason (Selling Guide). If a county assessor's recorded transfer shows a $1 deed or a quitclaim, discard it.

Comps vs. appraiser comps vs. a CMA

Comps are raw sold data you pull yourself. An appraiser's comps are the same idea, but adjusted and defended to underwriting standards. A CMA layers your adjustments and condition notes on top to produce a list price and seller's net sheet. Tools like Agent Copilot AI turn screened comps into that client-ready CMA, but the screening itself is yours.

Where can I find real estate comps in my neighborhood for free?

County assessor and recorder sites

Your county assessor publishes sale prices, lot sizes, square footage, and tax history for every recorded transaction. Most counties offer a free search by address or owner name. Recorder sites show the actual deed, which confirms the sale was arm's-length rather than a family transfer.

Zillow and Redfin sold filters

Both let you filter to sold listings within a radius and date range. Redfin's sold data tends to update faster and shows list-versus-sale price. Zillow shows price history on each property. Neither is perfect: some non-MLS sales never appear, and condition details are thin.

Your MLS sold data (the gold standard)

If you have MLS access, sold comps there beat everything else. You get DOM, list-to-sale ratio, concessions, and agent remarks that flag flipped or distressed sales. If you want the numbers turned into a seller's net sheet or a side-by-side offer comparison, our offer comparison tool formats them for you.

FSBO and off-market caveats

Free sources miss FSBO deals and off-market sales entirely. If a comp-heavy pocket has lots of FSBO activity, treat your estimate as a range, not a number.

Where the sources stack up:

  • County assessor β€” Free. Shows sold price: yes. Condition notes: no.
  • Zillow / Redfin sold β€” Free. Shows sold price: yes. Condition notes: rarely.
  • MLS sold β€” Membership. Shows sold price: yes. Condition notes: yes.
  • FSBO / off-market β€” Free. Shows sold price: sometimes. Condition notes: no.

How do I filter comps by radius, sale date, and property type?

Radius rules by market density

Start with a half-mile in dense urban neighborhoods, one mile in typical suburbs, and up to five miles in rural areas where sales are thin. If you pull fewer than three sales inside the radius, widen it before loosening any other filter. A comp across a highway, river, or school-district boundary often behaves like a different market, so discard it even if it's close.

Recency windows: 90 days vs 6 months

In an active market, use solds from the last 90 days. If inventory is slow, stretch to six months and adjust for any price movement since. Zillow's own help docs flag that sold data can lag or vary in accuracy by area, so verify anything borderline against your MLS before you rely on it (Zillow Help). Anything older than six months goes in the discard pile, not the adjustment pile.

Matching beds, baths, lot, and style

Keep comps within one bedroom and one bathroom of your subject, with lot size within about 20% and the same broad style: ranch to ranch, two-story to two-story. A 4/3 colonial won't price a 3/2 rambler, no matter how near it sold. Same rule applies to the marketing work: a staged photo set reads differently from an empty one, which is why we built virtual staging into the same toolbox you'd use to draft the listing.

When should I discard a comp as unreliable?

A comp is only as good as its story. If you cannot explain why it sold for what it did, it will mislead your seller's net sheet more than help it. Discard anything that fails the checklist below, even if it looks tempting on price.

The discard checklist

Throw out a comp when it fails any one of these:

  • Radius: more than a mile away in a suburban neighborhood, or across a natural boundary (highway, water, school zone) in a dense one.
  • Recency: closed more than 90 days ago in a market moving faster than 5% a quarter; up to 6 months is tolerable in a flat market.
  • Property type: different bed count band, lot size class, or condo versus single-family, no matter how close it sits.
  • Condition: a visible renovation, obvious deferred maintenance, or a sale photo that shows the kitchen was last touched in 1994.
  • Sale terms: any hint that the price was not set by the open market.

Run every candidate through all five before it earns a place in your analysis. Two good comps beat five shaky ones. If you want the screening to happen automatically as you build the pricing story for your listing, Agent Copilot AI's multi-channel tool applies the same filters to the comps you feed it, so stale sales stop sneaking into your numbers.

Non-arm's-length sales to throw out

Family-to-family transfers, sales between business partners, and estate sales to relatives are not market prices. A house that "sold" to the seller's brother for $410,000 tells you nothing about what a stranger would pay tomorrow. Check the grantor and grantee names on public records; matching last names are a red flag. Discard these every time, even when they are your only nearby sale.

Distressed sales and flips

Foreclosures, short sales, and as-is estate sales close below what a well-prepped listing would fetch, often by a wide margin. Flips are the mirror image: a renovated flip sets a ceiling for condition, not a baseline for your dated 3-bed. Both distort your range. Discard them unless you are pricing a property in the same condition, and say so in your notes.

How do I adjust a comp's price for differences in condition or upgrades?

Paired-sales adjustment method

Find two comps that are nearly identical except for one feature, say a renovated kitchen versus an original one. The price gap between them is your dollar value for that feature. Repeat across your comp set and you build adjustment figures rooted in your own market, not guesswork.

Fannie Mae's Selling Guide expects appraisers to make adjustments this way, based on market evidence rather than flat rules of thumb.

A worked example: $25/sq ft condition adjustment

Say your subject is updated and a comp sold at $300/sq ft in original condition. If paired sales in your area show $25/sq ft between updated and dated homes, add $25/sq ft to the comp's price. A 1,800 sq ft comp becomes an adjusted $345,000 baseline before you weigh other differences. Write the number down; illustrative figures like this only hold if your paired sales back them.

When adjustments exceed 15% and the comp fails

If your total adjustments push past roughly 15% of the comp's sale price, the comp is too different to trust. Discard it. If your adjusted values keep swinging, the Agent Copilot AI updates page covers how our CMA tool flags out-of-range comps automatically.

How many comps do I need before I trust my price estimate?

Three to six solid comps

Three comps that pass your screening checklist beat ten sloppy ones. With three to six recent, nearby, same-style sales, you can spot a consistent price-per-square-foot range and defend it in a listing presentation. Below three, one oddball sale swings your number too much. If your area is thin, widen the radius or go back another 90 days before you loosen the quality bar.

When the spread between comps is too wide

If your best comps differ by more than roughly 10-15% on price per square foot, you do not have a price estimate yet; you have a question. Something is off: a renovated flip next to dated originals, a different lot size, or a comp from the wrong subdivision. Discard the outlier, re-run your filters, and keep only comps that cluster. When you cannot get them to cluster, that stale or unusual listing needs adjustments or a full CMA, not a gut-call number.

When should I stop DIY-ing comps and run a full CMA?

Situations that demand a formal CMA

A quick comp pull is fine for a listing presentation or a weekly price check. Go formal when the stakes rise: a stale listing that needs a price cut backed by numbers, a seller with an unrealistic anchor, a property with unusual features (half-acre lot in a quarter-acre neighborhood, a finished basement comps can't match), or a contested estate or divorce situation where your number may be challenged. If two of your three comps needed heavy condition adjustments, you're past DIY territory.

Turning comps into a client-ready CMA and seller's net sheet

A formal CMA documents each adjustment, so the seller sees why the comp down the street supports your price. Paired-sales analysis, the standard method appraisers use to isolate what a feature is worth, is the basis for those adjustments (Appraisal Institute). Tools like Agent Copilot AI generate the CMA write-up and seller's net sheet from your screened comps, so a solo agent can deliver a top-producer package without building spreadsheets.

How do I present comps to sellers without losing the listing?

Sellers don't lose trust because your number is low. They lose trust because the number shows up with no receipts.

Showing the discard decisions builds trust

Bring your full comp sheet, including the comps you threw out. When a seller sees you rejected a sale two blocks away because it was a foreclosure or a dated sale from last season, your remaining comps look vetted, not cherry-picked. Pair each kept comp with a one-line reason: "same floor plan, sold 34 days ago, updated kitchen like yours."

Pairing comps with listing photos and staging

Show the seller side-by-side photos of comp homes against their own. If comparable homes sold at top dollar with staged, day-to-dusk quality photos, the seller sees the gap themselves. That sets up your marketing plan: professional listing photos, virtual staging where the home is empty, and an MLS description written to match the comps that sold fast. The comps justify the price, and the presentation justifies the comps.

FAQ

How do I find real estate comps in my area for free?

County assessor and recorder sites publish sold prices, square footage, and deed records at no cost. Zillow and Redfin both filter to sold listings by radius and date. If you have MLS access, its sold data beats both because it includes DOM, concessions, and agent remarks.

What is the radius for real estate comps?

Start with a half-mile in dense urban neighborhoods, one mile in typical suburbs, and up to five miles in rural areas. If you find fewer than three sales inside the radius, widen it before loosening other filters. Discard any comp across a highway, river, or school-district boundary.

How far back should comps go when pricing a house?

Use solds from the last 90 days in an active market. In a slow one, stretch to six months and adjust for price movement since then. Anything older than six months belongs in the discard pile. If your market moves faster than 5% a quarter, treat anything past 90 days as stale.

How many comps do appraisers use?

Appraisers typically work with three to six solid comparables. Three screened sales that pass every filter beat ten sloppy ones, because below three a single oddball sale swings your number too much. Appraisers defend each comp with paired-sales adjustments and discard any comp whose total adjustments exceed 15%.

Can I do a CMA without MLS access?

Yes, but treat the result as a range rather than a number. County records plus Zillow or Redfin sold filters give you prices and dates, but you lose DOM, concessions, and condition notes. Verify borderline sales against the recorder's deed, widen your filters cautiously, and document every discard.