Offer Comparison
Compare 2–5 offers side-by-side and get an AI-powered recommendation.
Listing Details
Offer 1
Offer 2
Multiple offers → Clear recommendation
Enter each offer's details and get an instant side-by-side analysis with a written recommendation.
3 Competing Offers
Offer 1 — Jane Smith Price: $755,000 | Down: 20% | Close: 30 days Contingencies: Inspection + financing Offer 2 — Marcus Lee Price: $740,000 | Down: 30% | Close: 21 days Contingencies: None (waived all) Offer 3 — The Johnsons Price: $760,000 | Down: 10% | Close: 45 days Contingencies: Inspection, financing, sale of current home
AI Comparison Summary
★ Strongest offer: Marcus Lee ($740K) While not the highest price, Marcus Lee's offer is the most compelling due to: • No contingencies — lowest risk of falling out of escrow • 30% down — strong financing, unlikely to have appraisal issues • 21-day close — fastest timeline The Johnsons' $760K is highest but the sale-of-home contingency is a significant risk. Jane Smith is a solid middle-ground backup.
How the offer comparison works
Enter the offers you have received and the tool lays them out side by side on the terms that decide which is strongest — price against list, deposit, financing, contingencies, timeline and any additional conditions — rather than on price alone. The result is a single view a seller can read in one pass.
The value of a like-for-like table is that it removes the noise. Offers arrive in different formats, written by different agents, with terms buried in different places. Normalising them onto the same rows is most of the work of comparing them, and it is the part that is tedious to do by hand at the exact moment you are least able to spare the time.
What actually separates two offers
Once the price difference is on the table, the questions that matter are about certainty. How much has the buyer put at risk if they walk away? Are they financing, and how far through that process are they? Which contingencies are in place, and how long does each one stay open? When does escrow close, and does that fit what the seller needs?
A seller looking at a $10,000 difference between two offers is looking at a real number, but it is a small one against the cost of a deal collapsing six weeks in and the property going back on the market as a listing that has visibly failed once. Framing the comparison as price versus probability of closing is usually the clearest way to have that conversation, and it is what a side-by-side view makes visible.
Presenting it to a seller
Give the seller the comparison before the conversation, not during it. Reading a table while being asked to decide produces anxiety rather than clarity, and the offer that gets chosen is often simply the one that was explained last. A document they have had time with changes the dynamic.
Walk the rows in order of what matters to that seller specifically. A seller who has already bought their next property cares about the closing date far more than one who has not. A seller who needs a specific number to clear their mortgage cares about net proceeds rather than headline price — which is where a net sheet alongside the comparison does more than either document does alone.
Where it fits with the other tools
The offer explainer and the offer comparison answer different questions. The explainer says what a single offer means in plain English, which is what a seller needs when the terms are unfamiliar. The comparison says which of several is stronger, which is what they need once they understand them. Used together, the explainer removes the jargon and the comparison makes the decision legible.
Adding a seller's net sheet completes the picture, because the question underneath every offer comparison is what the seller actually walks away with. Price, terms and net proceeds are three different numbers, and sellers routinely conflate them.
Every tool on Agent Copilot AI is included in one $29-per-month plan with unlimited use, rather than being billed per image or per document. There is a 7-day free trial and no credit card is required to start, so you can run a real listing through it before deciding.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does it compare?
The terms that determine which offer is strongest — price against list, deposit, financing, contingencies, timeline and additional conditions — laid out side by side rather than ranked on price alone.
How is this different from the offer explainer?
The explainer translates a single offer into plain English. The comparison puts several offers side by side so a seller can see which is stronger. Most agents use the explainer first and the comparison second.
Should I send it before the decision call?
Yes. A seller reading a comparison table for the first time while being asked to decide tends to default to the offer explained most recently. Giving them time with it changes the conversation to judgement.
Does a higher price always win?
No. A higher offer with a financing contingency, a long escrow and a small deposit can be worth less than a lower one that is more certain to close. The comparison is designed to make that visible.
Should I pair it with a net sheet?
Usually, yes. Price, terms and net proceeds are three different numbers and sellers often conflate them. A net sheet answers the question underneath the comparison: what do I actually walk away with?
Related tools
More AI tools built for real estate agents.
Offer explainer
Translate complex offer terms into plain English your clients understand.
AI CMA generator
Build a client-ready comparative market analysis in minutes.
MLS description writer
Generate Fair Housing-compliant MLS copy from the property's features.
